Contact Us: Email
Ph: 919-669-9111
Fx: 919-573-9595

Subscribe To
Insurance Advice
And Dispute Blog
Join Here

To Hire ICG
Complete This

Appraisal Form

[ Cast A Vote for Useful Information Page ]

Insurance Dispute Held Up Demolition of Fatal Fire Site

Posted by Joe Brennan | Posted in Appraisal Umpire, Fire Insurance Claims, Homeowners Insurance, Independent Appraiser, Insurance Advice, Insurance Claims Help, Insurance Dispute | Posted on 09-15-2010


Insurance DisputeAn insurance dispute held up the demolition of a house destroyed by fire for over a year. Unfortunately, this type of situation can happen. In fact, some disputes can last even two to three years or longer. Even more unfortunate than the loss of the home was the loss of two family members who died in the fire.

The following story was broadcast by WRAL News on May 7, 2008 – one year to the day they covered the original story about the fire itself. This story has personal affects on me as I was the independent appraiser for the insured in this case. 

WRAL News – The May 7, 2007, fire at 1884 Memorial Church Road, in Fremont, claimed the lives of Shannon Minshew and her 77-year-old, bed-ridden grandmother, Mayola Waddell.

Firefighters found Minshew’s body on top of Waddell. She had been trying to save her, investigators said. “It’s horrible we have to see it (the home) every day, whenever we go somewhere,” said Minshew’s daughter, Brandy Hall, who lives behind the charred home.

Other family members live next door and directly across the street. The entire family is fighting with Nationwide Insurance to get the house demolished.

Nationwide declined to comment on the matter Wednesday, but Minshew’s family says the insurance company has not determined how much it is willing to pay on the property.

The family says it doesn’t care about the money. They only want to have the charred remains of the home removed. “It’s hurting all of us even worse, and we’re getting tired of seeing it every day,” Minshew’s son, Tyler Hall, said. “It needs to be torn down.”  –  WRAL End  –

Terrible loss from this fire – not only the loss of the home, but also the loss of two loved ones suffered by this family. My prayers still go out to them today.

Funny is this comment by the family, “…the insurance company has not determined how much it is willing to pay…“. Willing to pay? How about the amount it actually costs to replace the damaged home – not a penny more, nor a penny less? See, this is the mentality of many insurance company representatives. (Notice how I said many and not all – some actually know the policy and how to execute it’s coverage. However, they are few and far between.) By stating to this insured that we have not calculated how much we are “willing” to pay, shows that they are not interested in paying what they owe, but rather how much they can save. How much can they offer to make the insured go away.

As I mentioned, I was the independent appraiser hired by the insured on this loss. They had a public adjuster who could not obtain a settlement on the claim. Nationwide invoked the Appraisal Clause on February 11 2010 and I was named as the appraiser for the homeowners on February 19, 2009 – more than nine (9) months after the date the fire occurred.

The building was insured for $125,300. Nationwide calculated that the home could be rebuilt for $103,700 ($21,600 less than it was covered for). Nationwide mailed the insured a check for $90,468.00 for “Actual Cash Value” after applying depreciation to their Replacement Cost number. (The rebuild at $103,700.)

The dispute on how much it would cost to replace the damaged home continued into the appraisal where the court was petitioned to select a “competent and disinterested” umpire.

Fortunately the claim was settled by myself and Nationwide’s appraiser within four (4) months and did not require the services of the umpire. The Appraisal Award ended up as follows:

  • Policy Limit: $125,300
  • Nationwide’s Offer:  RCV – $103,700  –  ACV – $90,468
  • Appraisal Award:  RCV – $140,500  –  ACV – $140,200

In conclusion, the insurance appraisal process resulted in $36,800 more than what was offered by Nationwide Insurance for RCV and $49,732 more than Nationwide offered for ACV. The insured was also paid $14,900 more than there policy limit of $125,300.

Certainly we have had larger appraisals where the policyholder has obtained “hundreds of thousands” of dollars more than the insurance company had offered. However, most would agree that no one would want to eat $49,732 to line the pockets of their carrier. For this family, it was about two loved ones, Shannon Minshew and Mayola Waddell, not about the property or the money.

Anyway, I ran across the WRAL News story online while searching for something else. It reminded me that the loss of property can be replaced… However, loved ones cannot.

(In an effort to show both sides of the coin, my next post involving an insurance dispute will be about how some policyholders try to claim fraudulent damage on claims that enter into appraisal as well.)

[ Cast A Vote for Useful Information Page ]

(C) Joe Brennan is President and owner/operator of Insurance Claims Group, Inc., a national independent adjusting, appraisal, and umpiring firm. We will answer your claim questions FREE as part of our FREE Insurance Advice and Insurance Claim Consulting Services.

Insurance Claims Group, Inc.
Joe Brennan
Ph: 919-669-9111
Fx: 919-573-9595

Insurance Claim Help and questions about Independent Appraiser Services is available by visiting Insurance Claims Group | Insurance Appraisal Services | Insurance Appraisal Process | Insurance Appraisal Umpire | Fire Insurance Claims